Cup pa Coffee | Your New Favorite Coffee Destination in Hannibal, NY

Overview

Cup pa Coffee is a charming coffee shop nestled in the heart of Hannibal, NY, that stands out as a hidden gem for both locals and travelers alike. Located conveniently along NY 104, it offers a warm, inviting space where coffee lovers can experience carefully crafted beverages alongside a friendly, community-oriented atmosphere.

Their menu strikes a perfect balance between classic and creative. Whether you favor a robust dark roast or a smooth mocha latte, each cup promises quality and depth of flavor. Their cold brew and iced lattes have garnered particular praise for their smooth texture and well-rounded taste—perfect for those seeking a refreshing pick-me-up. Beyond coffee, the selection of teas and specialty drinks like the London Fog and Peak Energy Black demonstrate thoughtful variety for different palates.

Food-wise, Cup pa Coffee is beginning to carve out a niche with thoughtful offerings such as sourdough breakfast sandwiches and peanut butter balls, hinting at an evolving menu that aims to complement their drinks beautifully. Customers note the future inclusion of sweet treats like cream puffs, enhancing the overall appeal for those who value both quality and culinary creativity.

What elevates the experience at Cup pa Coffee is the staff’s genuine warmth and hospitality. Reviews consistently mention staff members—Amy, Anna, Shannon—going above and beyond by offering samples and personalized recommendations, creating a welcoming vibe that feels like stepping into a close-knit community gathering spot rather than just a coffee stop. This blend of personable service and high-quality offerings makes it a destination coffee shop that appeals to a wide audience, from commuters craving a quick espresso to families looking for a cozy hangout.

For those navigating along NY 104 or making a trip to Rochester, Cup pa Coffee offers a refreshing pause—not just a caffeine fix, but an experience marked by flavorful drinks, thoughtful eats, and genuine human connection. It’s a place worth discovering, where every visit feels like coming home to a familiar, well-loved neighborhood cafe.

Amenities & Services

Offerings

Coffee

Atmosphere

Casual

What Customers Say

Jennifer Ruggio

Dec 3,2025

5/5

I just got back from the PNW, where these same similar coffee shops are popped up along the road side!! Cuppa Coffee was a wonderful experience and I had a delicious Salted Caramel Latte!! Amy greeted me with a variety of samples of tasty lemonade and great information on her new coffee shop!! Stop by and check it out!! Highly recommend!

Megan Vivlemore

Dec 3,2025

5/5

10/10 every time. I’ve been maybe 6 times now and I always get an iced latte and they’re the best I’ve ever had. I tried their sourdough breakfast sandwich and let me just say I’ll be back for those probably every day. They’re also super nice every time I go and I’ve had almost everyone who works there I believe.

Gerri Domicolo

Dec 3,2025

5/5

Just stopped and ordered the Dubai Chocolate Frappe! So incredibly delicious. I love that I could taste the espresso and it wasn’t just another super sweet coffee drink. Anna was amazing and so sweet. Really an enjoyable experience. Prices are very fair with plenty of choices and flavors to choose from. I’ll definitely need to try the avocado toast next time! Also, there was a very sweet little girl, whose name I won’t share with out permission, but she was doll. Definitely worth the drive from Oswego. Lots of Love from the “Wild Girls”

Bethany Germain

Dec 3,2025

5/5

Been wanting to try for awhile, but you have to be on the lookout to stop. Today on the way to Rochester, got coffees and peanut butter balls. We stopped on the way home for smoothies and apple bars. All delish! Will definitely return

Gabriella Gauger

Dec 3,2025

5/5

We’ve been hearing about this little coffee shop for a while now and decided to go check it out for ourselves! Way cuter than we’d thought possible. Shannon was an absolute sweetie and gave us a couple of cream puff samples. She said they’re going to start incorporating food soon! It’s gonna be hard not to stop every time I drive past here now…

Madison Wilson

Dec 3,2025

5/5

I got the Dubai Chocolate Pistachio Crunch Frappe and ohhhh my goodness I can’t stop sucking it down!! My partner got a hot black coffee and says ooo that’s good coffee The women running it are absolutely amazing, sweet, fun, genuine people! I didn’t have cash on me to leave a tip so they get double next time! We will 100% be back again! Absolutely charming spot in a great location right off 104, tooons of coffee and espresso options as well as non caffeinated options and milk alternatives They have it all, it was so hard to choose.

Aaron

Dec 3,2025

5/5

I order every Wednesday, just once a week. They remember my order every time. The coffee is fresh and very well balanced. The breakfast sandwich is amazing!

RYAN PRITCHARD

Dec 3,2025

5/5

Favorite thing to do whenever I'm travelling or on the road is find local coffee shops. Up until a few months ago the best coffee I had was in a small beach town on the Atlantic in FL.... Then I stopped in just down the road to Cuppa... No exaggerating this was and continues to be the best coffee I've ever had. I pretty consistently find myself driving the round about route or clear out of my way to swing through and grab a drink. I cannot recommend this place enough!